Sign In
New User? Sign Up
robertpirsig · Robert Pirsig - Robert Pirsig Discussion Group
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!7

Yahoo!7 Groups Tips

Did you know...
You can search the group for older messages.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
Robert Pirsig   Message List  
Reply | Forward Message #38 of 88 |
Commentys on comments

Geoff said:<br><br>&gt;Bo, I find how you said
that society and &gt;technology has advanced
interesting. <br>&gt;Vegetable-like Humans without the
technoloy &gt;currently available would not be able to
survive &gt;and in a way this is intefering with God's
(if &gt;you beleive in him/her/it) or Natures natural
&gt;path. It is in fact inhuman to keep a person &gt;alive
that has no possiblilty to recover.<br><br>Hi
Geoff.<br>My opinion is that it should be possible for the
individual to make up a last will to the effect of actively
putting an end to one's life (not merely as it is in this
country to ask for the treatment to stop), but for those
who refuse it should not become a rule.<br><br>
************<br><br>Hi Sara <br>You had so many good and subtle points
(a true philosopher)that I better answer in a
roundabout way. Yes, in LILA Pirsigs says that society has
no moral right to use capital punishment, but that's
not exactly the point here. <br><br>I agree that
nothing human is "natural" (except our biology) and can
hardly be a measure. The above (for Geoff) is my opinion
on the issue: if no written consent is available no
general "killing off", but in my opening piece I used
Netherlands' law (proposal?) as an example without really
knowing what it implies. Can you tell? Re. the MoQ slant
on it all is that this issue is the "social value"
at work. What (in Norway) is called "life's
testament" is an heroic act. I have done so myself and
regard it as my DUTY - a dominant social pattern!
<br><br>Finally you said: <br>&gt;Looking from a more cosmic
angle, I think God, &gt;or truth or beauty or Good or
universality or &gt;oneness or QUALITY (whatever you call it,
but &gt;dont be fooled, we all believe in something!)
is &gt;an all-encompassing wider notion than even
&gt;nature. <br><br>Yes, definitely, the very Q idea is that
all existence is based on "belief" (though not in
SOM's "subjective" sense)which is another word for
value-perception at distinct levels. Inorganic belief, Biological
belief ..etc. At the evolutionary top floor - Intellect
- the beliefs become rather complicated - yet
...<br><br>&gt;And though we are part of the universe, and have
&gt;glimpses of beauty, etc, we cannot ever 'know it &gt;all'
as we are just small, fallible, bits of a &gt;wider
'truth' which is allways there and outside &gt;of the
mortal or transient. <br><br>Er..well the notion of
truth is THE major Intellectual pattern - Q-intellect
that is, in the subject/object world one is forced to
alternate between subjective (beliefs) and objective
(knowledge) and both leads into blind alleys. <br><br>&gt;I
dont find it useful or meaningful to attribute &gt;a
'will' or a pre-defined 'way' to this notion &gt;of
God/QUALITY.<br>&gt;I dont see this universal concept as attributed
&gt;with answers for precise human quandries.<br><br>May I
add a very general and perhaps irrelevant note on
your God/Quality "aggregate" which is most apt IMO.
The gods of the myths, be it Greek or Norse or
whatever, were persons with wills of their own, but then
everything in their universe was WILL, they simply had no
notion of any objective realm beyond the subjects. This
is so horribly important in the understanding of the
Quality idea. My - um - belief is that even the mosaic
God was such an universal will, but that the emerging
intellect (which in Greece gave rise to the
truth/false=objective/subjective)resulted in the God/World split of
Christianity. This is
of such enormous proportions that a cultural history
could be written on it, but this is the limit that the
Yahoo demon allows. <br>Thanks for reading.<br>Bo




Mon May 7, 2001 5:49 am

bo34no
Send Email Send Email

Forward
Message #38 of 88 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

Not that it's going to change anything, but were Chris Pirsig's killers ever "brought to justice"? I've not been able to find anything about that on the...
yah_me
Offline Send Email
May 5, 2001
8:32 pm

Geoff said:<br><br>&gt;Bo, I find how you said that society and &gt;technology has advanced interesting. <br>&gt;Vegetable-like Humans without the technoloy...
bo34no
Offline Send Email
May 7, 2001
5:49 am

A brief, first reply to your interesting, but confusing mail! Call me thick, but I found it difficult to follow your point! A few initial points and ...
caledonia1963
Offline Send Email
May 8, 2001
10:41 am

Halooo...<br>Is there anybody out there?<br>Was it something I wrote, or is it holiday time for everyone?<br>Has noone anything to say or discuss about ...
caledonia1963
Offline Send Email
May 17, 2001
11:04 am

Sorry for not posting lately.<br><br>The reason is that I have exams approaching next week so I have been hard at study.<br><br>After next week and a bit, I...
enlightenedphilosopher
enlightenedp...
Offline Send Email
May 18, 2001
6:01 am

Hi Pirsig Club.<br>We suddenly got relatives visiting from the USA and I had to act the host, but now things are back to normal.<br><br>For Geoff.<br>Stay with...
bo34no
Offline Send Email
May 18, 2001
9:23 am

GOOOD LUCK with your studies Geoff - what's your subject(s)?<br>You didn't mention how you got on with ZMM the 2nd time around - any flashy, quick comments in...
caledonia1963
Offline Send Email
May 18, 2001
5:48 pm

Hi KA<br>You did not get any response to your question about the murder of Chris Pirsig, but I'm afraid that I have no new information on the matter other than...
bo34no
Offline Send Email
May 23, 2001
6:59 am

Update,<br><br>I have now completed 2 of my 5 exams.<br>English and Economics have been completed,<br>Accounting, Math with Stats and Classical Studies ...
enlightenedphilosopher
enlightenedp...
Offline Send Email
May 25, 2001
11:41 pm

Pirsig fans.<br>Internet discussions seem to have only two modes: full ahead and dead stop. I participate in another site (Colin Wilson) which is overflowing...
bo34no
Offline Send Email
May 31, 2001
6:57 pm

HI Bo and all (all 2 of us regulars!!??? say something, anything , someone else, PLEASE!!!)<br><br>Im back from a sailing week (as mate, and singing ...
caledonia1963
Offline Send Email
Jun 1, 2001
11:27 am

Hi Bo, Sara & all,<br><br>I agree that Pirsig needs a popularizer. The brutal volume of advertising that hits people every day makes it difficult for them to...
joao_csilva
Offline Send Email
Jun 1, 2001
5:27 pm

Hallo Joao<br>Nice to here another voice here - where are you writing from - Brazil? <br>(I have a fascination with Bahia as I co-own a saveiro buiklt in ...
caledonia1963
Offline Send Email
Jun 2, 2001
10:22 am

Hello Sara, Bo, Joao & all,<br><br>I’ve been keeping away from potential discussions, as I really need to reread both Lila and ZMM. <br><br>Sara, I like ...
discoverylover
Offline Send Email
Jun 2, 2001
3:23 pm

Joao and Club.<br>I thought we had met before - at the Lila Squad perhaps - but see that you are a Wilson club member too. OK that's fine, you'll perhaps have...
bo34no
Offline Send Email
Jun 3, 2001
8:21 am

I think a popularizer of Pirsig are in fact his many readers. My brother's friend recommended that I read 'ZMM'. This 'word of mouth' allowed me to discover...
enlightenedphilosopher
enlightenedp...
Offline Send Email
Jun 3, 2001
8:27 am

Yes Geoff, and what I was trying to add in my mailings was that, it is by being affected by Pirsig and seeing how quality can be achieved in every day in our ...
caledonia1963
Offline Send Email
Jun 3, 2001
11:43 am

Bo, I find what you wrote interesting; I’m waiting for a continuation....
discoverylover
Offline Send Email
Jun 3, 2001
12:22 pm

                            ...
joao_csilva
Offline Send Email
Jun 3, 2001
4:13 pm

Hallo Clubbers... & Wow Joao!<br>A lot of words, and ethusiasm, and desperation about the state of the world - but I'm not clear about your message or question...
caledonia1963
Offline Send Email
Jun 4, 2001
8:53 am

Hi Bo<br>My version of ZMM did not have the afterword you mention here. I am curious, perhaps rather sensationally, and I know I should really concentrate on...
caledonia1963
Offline Send Email
Jun 4, 2001
9:10 am

For Diana: <br>As said I launched this my "change-over-time" idea at another site but was informed that a science-writer, Robert A. Wilson, had anticipated it...
bo34no
Offline Send Email
Jun 5, 2001
7:31 am

Hi Sara,<br>You can find the afterword here:<br><a href=http://www.virtualschool.edu/mon/Quality/PirsigZen/afterword.html...
joao_csilva
Offline Send Email
Jun 5, 2001
3:38 pm

Hey Jaoa<br>I checked out the Tao of Poo site a coupkle of days ago. Very sweet! I still have fond memories or being read Poo as a child in Scotland. ...
caledonia1963
Offline Send Email
Jun 8, 2001
10:11 am

Thanks for this Jaoa...<br>I found it deeply sad, but beautifully written piece.<br>COndolences to him and all who have suffered the loss of a close loved ...
caledonia1963
Offline Send Email
Jun 10, 2001
7:50 am

Sara, I think I understand what you are saying about pain. It seems to me that pain helps me ‘unlock’ myself; it opens a kind of sensitivity in me....
discoverylover
Offline Send Email
Jun 10, 2001
10:25 pm

Hi all!<br>Diana - yes, I like your description about how pain helps us. I too am rather vague about the process, as this is the first time in my life I am...
caledonia1963
Offline Send Email
Jun 12, 2001
7:55 am

Hi Sara and Pirsig readers.<br>This small "club" is such an relaxing place compared to the bedlam of the Lila Squad and I should beware of introducing any ...
bo34no
Offline Send Email
Jun 13, 2001
7:46 am

OK it may be relaxed here Bo, but i dont mind a bit of controversy to stir the cobwebs in my brain!<br>What is the particular shocker you were aluding to in ...
caledonia1963
Offline Send Email
Jun 15, 2001
8:53 am

Hi all! <br><br>May I come in? <br><br>I'm glad to enter this small club. I'd say it's relaxing, as I'm used to the crowded *agora* of MD and MF. Someone of...
deadlytoy
Offline Send Email
Jun 22, 2001
6:00 pm
 First  |  |  Last 
< Prev Topic  |  Next Topic >
Advanced

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Australia & NZ Pty Ltd. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help